Making Macarons

Why hello everyone! I am back at it this week with something I have not done in a while: a baking project! As someone who likes to bake, but doesn’t really enjoy following recipes precisely, I had never tried to make macarons which are notoriously difficult cookies. However, my fiancé, Sean, thought it was time for another baking project on the blog and agreed to help me out.

We followed this Macaron Recipe from a blog called Preppy Kitchen: https://preppykitchen.com/french-macarons/. Overall, it was a great recipe so I would recommend giving it a try!

To start off, I wouldn’t say that this recipe is something you can just make on a whim as I did have to buy a few things specifically for this recipe. Maybe other people have more sophisticated pantries than we do, but we did not already have almond flour or cream of tartar. I also want to say right here that anything that went slightly wrong with this recipe is almost certainly because Sean and I did not follow it closely enough so the blame definitely lies on us and not the recipe.

We needed three egg whites at room temperature so we took some eggs out of the fridge to warm up a bit. I will admit that they were still slightly chilled when we ended up using them, but were not fridge cold. The first step was sifting almond flour and powdered sugar and we forgot that we had a decent sifter so we used this slightly rusty one that wasn’t that functional which led to our dry ingredients not being the smoothest. We then proceeded to find our better sifter so we would definitely use that going forward and probably would sift the ingredients twice just to be safe.

We then whipped the eggs whites as instructed and added in the sugar, cream of tartar and dry ingredients. We decided to make these into pumpkin spice macarons so added some pumpkin spice and food coloring to the batter. The directions said that the batter was supposed to flow like lava and I think our batter was slightly chunkier than lava might be, but it wasn’t too bad. We originally forgot to add the vanilla and the batter definitely improved in texture upon adding that.

We put the batter into a piping bag with a round tip and then piped small-ish circles of batter onto cookie sheets covered with parchment paper. We banged the trays on the table to release air bubbles and let the batter sit for about 40 minutes per the instructions. I also proceeded to add sprinkles to a few of the macaron tops even though Sean and I had agreed to not add any sprinkles. I live life on the wild side.

While the macaron cookies were sitting out we started working on the buttercream filling. I will say that the buttercream filling, while delicious, did not have the best viscosity. I am also not sure if viscosity is the correct word here but I'm trying to say that the filling was somehow too thick and too melty at the same time. But again I will admit that we did not follow the recipe exactly. We were supposed to heat a water and sugar syrup up to precisely 240 degrees, but we do not have a candy thermometer so I kind of just guesstimated what I thought that temperature would be.

We were also supposed to use unsalted butter and then add a small amount of salt, but we instead used salted butter. So those deviations from the recipe may have changed the filling. It was delicious, but the filing couldn’t be out of the fridge for more than about 5 minutes or it would just start melting.

Once the cookies had sat out for 40 minutes we baked them for about 14 minutes and turned the trays halfway. The cookies came out really well! They had a pretty smooth, hard top and chewy center which is what you are looking for with a macaron cookie.

We let the cookies cool and the filling harden in the fridge a bit and then assembled our macarons.

And here they are!

Sean and I were both pretty impressed with how these came out. They were delicious when we first assembled the cookies, but were even better the next few days once the filling had soaked into the cookie a bit. The main takeaways from this baking experience were that macarons are actually not as difficult to make as we thought, but that accuracy in following the recipe is key. Happy baking everyone!

- Rebecca